Beth Ditto's Fashion Escapade

Sep 18, 2007 @ 4:21pm

BethBeachChair.jpg In June, we wrote about how British wunderkind Christopher Kane is collaborating with Beth Ditto on an outfit for October's Swarovski Fashion Rocks concert.

If you can't wait to see what vibrant outfit these two have cooked up, whet your appetite with the Autumn 2007 issue of Pop, which features a spread shot by Steven Klein of Ditto traipsing about in fashions both off-the-runway (Prada, Yves Saint Laurent) and made specially for the magazine (Gareth Pugh, Louis Vuitton, Proenza Schouler). Both humorous and poignant, the photos have that Paris, Texas vibe of wanderlust and adventure with the jet-set styles to match.

The accompanying article proclaims Beth Ditto is a "size hero," an icon both revered and criticized for representing an alternative to fashion's willowy norm. It also explores some of the underlying skepticism surrounding the singer's rise to fame and fashion notoriety.

Is the style world embracing Beth Ditto out of a genuine interest in her art and message or is it using her in a bid to establish itself as a tolerant community? Is all this hoopla over her image overshadowing what's important - her artistry and originality?

Discuss.

--NATALIE GUEVARA

BethBeachChair.jpg
Lounging around in a Prada top and skirt; bonnet by Yves Saint Laurent.

BethBus.jpg
The wheels on the bus go... Beth modeling a dress by Julie Verhoeven for Mulberry; clutch by Louis Vuitton.

BethChair.jpg
Dress made specially for POP by Hussein Chayalan.

BethGarethDress.jpg
Modeling a slashed dress made specially for POP by Gareth Pugh; shoes by Marc Jacobs.

BethGarethDress2.jpg
Ripped to shreds; another shot of Gareth's Tim Burton-ish masterpiece.

BethYSLCoat.jpg
Strolling along in a YSL coat; headscarf and bracelet both by Marc Jacobs; shoes by Repetto.

BethTakesALeap.jpg
Clad in a top and skirt both made specially for POP by Proenza Schouler, Beth takes a glorious leap.

Comments

avatar

posted by jessica.

Sep 18, 2007 5:00PM

To answer your question, I think that yes, it is using her to "establish itself as a tolerant community".

It's evident that Beth Ditto is not the size of Sasha, Freja, Anja or Ali. But is promoting her size really what the industry wants? I know that none of those models I just mentioned are a healthy weight. But neither is Ms Ditto. I'm all for putting plus size models on the runway, because it's obvious that models aren't there because of their health. But that's as long as we're talking about appearance and not health. I don't agree with comments like about how she's a healthy weight and a 'size hero'. Because she isn't. She's just as unhealthy as the bone-thin girls walking the runways. I appreciate the fact that she's thumbing her nose at fashion world stereotypes, but that should be the reason why we admire her. For her creativity, her music, her rebellion. Her not-giving-a-damn attitude. Not because she is overweight.

On lighter note: I do love that firt picture. The colours and photography is amazing.

avatar

posted by m

Sep 18, 2007 5:21PM

I think these photos look fantastic! I love how they're styled, like shoots with thin models often are, to highlight the strangeness and newness of the clothes. Usually, I think, you see editors just try to "prettify" larger models.

avatar

posted by Rebe

Sep 18, 2007 5:24PM

I agree with Jessica. I love Beth Ditto's music, but she is not at a healthy weight, not at all. Her face is beautiful in these photographs, I'll give her that. But the weight does not sit well on her. She is morbidly obese, and is not a good example of a healthy, gorgeous fuller figured woman ----- and these exist, in spades!

Sophie Dahl looked healthy as a size 14. Krystal Wren, ditto.

As for, um, Ditto? I think that it would send the wrong message if her body was considered a good alternative. She represents the opposite end of the spectrum, the reverse the equally appalling, bony forms of Irina L and Vlada and numerous other. Neither extreme should be embraced IMO. But we live in an era of extremes.

avatar

posted by Donna Kay

Sep 18, 2007 5:32PM

I agree with Jessica. Promoting a healthy weight would be preferable to someone who is obese and putting their future health in danger by being so.

This spread would have been better if they had portrayed her as pretty or even beautiful in some of the pics. Instead, she looks unhappy and even downright strange in them. If you're going to promote large women, the least you can do is show them as beautiful as Kate Moss etc. are constantly shown.

avatar

posted by

Sep 18, 2007 6:21PM

she makes me sick. she is unhealthy- just as unhealthy as irina or lily or natasha

avatar

posted by smarter fashion

Sep 18, 2007 9:02PM

Okay guys, yeah, she's overweight, but should she be forced to stay indoors and diet until she can reach her goal weight? Especially when she can produce cool, fashion-forward photos like this? Give me a break--she's not promoting anything but herself.

I'm a advocate of physical fitness, but I don't begrudge overweight people success and visibility. The fashion industry is the epitome of unhealthy lifestyles - why is it such a big deal for a fat girl to put on some nice clothes? Sheesh!

BTW, I love the Paris, Texas reference!

avatar

posted by margo

Sep 18, 2007 9:04PM

I definitely think that her popularity is a positive thing. While I still don't want to look like her (I don't care what Keira Knightley claims), but its admirable. Natalie should write more (too obvious?)

avatar

posted by Bobby

Sep 18, 2007 11:43PM

magazine's embrace of beth ditto is purely a P.R. shtick, and an ugly one at that. luckily for beth ditto, it seems her heart's still in music and this fashion thing is just for kicks.

avatar

posted by una

Sep 19, 2007 8:19AM

She's talented regardless of weight, so i would love if she would just shut up about the weight thing, Magazines use her because she's cool, and cool sells not because she's changing something in the fashion world, skinny women still look better. Christopher Kane irritates me particulary, he wants us to believe that a good marketing strategie that is using an indie icon like Beth Ditto to model his clothes is some sort of brave thing to do...

avatar

posted by Cynthia C

Sep 19, 2007 8:38AM

Honestly, if they're going to promote healthier figures, it's probably better to use, say, America Ferrera (sans airbrushing/stretching or whatever you want to call her Oct. Glamour cover) or a plus-sized model than Beth Ditto. She's got a pretty face, but she needs to look after her body a little more.

avatar

posted by Mimi

Sep 19, 2007 11:41AM

I'm glad you are still loving Beth Ditto, Fashionista, though these comments are making me crazy. I'm not sure why total strangers believe that they diagnose Ditto's health from looking at these photographs....

avatar

posted by ehkca

Sep 19, 2007 12:03PM

Can we all just stop making judgments and assumptions about people, their motives, their lifestyles, and their health. She maybe unhealthy, she may be perfectly fine, what does it matter? She exists the way she is and why should she be invisible?

What I want to know is where did she get Prada and YSL etc in her size? Were they made especially for her, because I sure can't find them in my size and I'm not as big as her.

avatar

posted by astralgirl01

Sep 20, 2007 5:15PM

RE: ehkca...

Yeah, where is she finding this gear? They didn't say "specially made," so are they making plus-sized garb somewhere in the world? I'm a proud size 14, and would cough up the cash in a hot minute if I could find it...

But I agree also with the person who said that Beth doesn't look happy to be in the clothes...

Post Your Comment